|
Developing
Research Skills
More
and more teachers are using the Internet with their students to
conduct research. The Internet offers unparalleled opportunities
to research a topic in depth; locate additional sources of information;
develop students' technology, critical thinking, and research skills;
and communicate with experts at a distance.
This
section contains information and resources to aid in teachers' overall
understanding of Internet research and why Internet research skills
are so important for adolescent learners. We also describe online
research process models, offer tips for teaching online research,
and provide instructional approaches.
What
is Internet Research? | Online Research Process
Skills Students Need | Paraphrasing | Teaching
Tips
What
is Internet Research?
Internet
research is the ability to access, comprehend, and apply electronic
information. It is a critical skill that all students must acquire
in order to compete in today's society, a society that relies heavily
on the Internet for the acquisition and dissemination of information.
Internet research, like all research techniques before it (using
a card catalogue, searching through microfiche, picking books off
of a shelf at the library), brings with it a new set of proficiencies
that must be taught and learned.
Below
we have provided recommended resources that describe Internet research.
Sites
That Matter
Grazing
the Net: Raising a Generation of Free Range Students
Jamie McKenzie outlines the power of the Internet for motivating
students to become "Infotectives," students who are able
to explore, analyze, sort, decipher, contemplate, think, invent,
create, and make meaning of information for themselves.
www.fno.org/text/grazing.html
Conducting
Research on the Internet
This article describes the different ways to locate information
on the Internet, including going directly to a site, browsing the
Web, using subject directories and search engines, joining computer-mediated
discussions, and using "invisible webs" (content that
is stored in databases accessible on the Web but not available via
search engines). It also provides practical tips for formulating
and conducting searches.
library.albany.edu/internet/research.html
Online
Searching versus Research
This site provides a chart that illustrates the difference between
searching for information and conducting research online.
www.virtualchase.com/researchskills/basic_skills3.html
CyberSmart!
Curriculum
Developed by the CyberSmart School Program and MacMillan McGraw-Hill,
this web site offers a free K-8 curriculum for teaching students
how to use the Internet safely, productively, and responsibly. The
site provides curriculum guides, lesson plans, activity sheets,
safety tips, and free downloadable posters. The CyberSmart curriculum
is also aligned with and links to the International Society for
Technology in Education's (ISTE) National Educational Technology
Standards (NETS) Performance Indicators.
www.cybersmartcurriculum.org/home
Online Research
Process
Before
teachers begin teaching students the Internet research skills they
need to compete in the 21st century, students must develop a thorough
knowledge of the research process in general. Below we describe
several research models to help teachers get started.
1.
The Research Cycle
Because
students now have access to such a huge array of electronic information,
Jamie McKenzie, a leading educational technologist for the past
decade, insists that schools must reinvent "the way they engage
students in both questioning and research." McKenzie's Research
Cycle Model takes into account the necessary skills needed before,
during, and after beginning research on the Internet. It includes
the following key elements: Questioning (BeforeNet), Planning (BeforeNet),
Gathering (On the Net), Sorting and Sifting (AfterNet), Synthesizing
(AfterNet), Evaluating (AfterNet), and Reporting (AfterNet).
Initially
published in Multimedia Schools, May/June 1995, McKenzie updated
his original research process, adapting it for the new millenium.
Now found in chapter eight of his book, Beyond Technology: Questioning,
Research and the Information Literate School, teachers can download
"The Research Cycle" at:
questioning.org/rcycle.html
2.
10 Essential Research Skills
Rich
Thome, district superintendent for the Cardiff School District in
California, has developed "10 Essential Research Skills"
that all students need to acquire in order to use the Internet to
its maximum research potential. In his article, "The Fourth
R is Research" (Electronic Learning, October 1996), Thome describes
each of the 10 essential research skills, from defining and narrowing
search topics and using search engines, to reviewing, evaluating,
and organizing resources.
To
access "The Fourth R is Research: It's time to recognize information
skills as crucial for our students," go to:
www.cedpa-k12.org/databus-issues/v37n1/fourth.html
3.
The I-Search Curriculum Unit
The
I-Search is one type of inquiry-based research process frequently
used in middle and high school classrooms. The term "I-Search"
was coined by Ken Macrorie in his book The I-Search Paper
(Heinemann, 1988). The overall goal of the I-Search is to actively
engage students in the research process as they pursue questions
of importance that they care about. In Ken Macrorie's words, through
the I-Search a student can satisfy "a genuine itch" that
needs to be scratched "until you've quieted it." Sometimes
an individual teacher engages students in the I-Search, while other
times a unit is carried out by an interdisciplinary team.
A version
of the I-Search Curriculum Unit was developed by Education
Development Center, Inc. (EDC). After developing and testing
a unit with four phases of instruction, EDC helped schools across
the country to design, implement, and evaluate I-Search units. In
addition, within the ScienceQuest
Project, EDC translated the basic process into a curriculum
for after-school programs.
To
learn more, see Literacy Matters' section on the I-Search
Curriculum Unit.
4.
The Big6 Skills Approach
The
Big6 approach to teaching information and technology skills
is the most widely used online research approach in the world. It
is taught in thousands of K-12 schools, institutes of higher education,
and adult training programs. Big6 specifically focuses on
developing the necessary problem-solving, search, evaluation, and
utilization skills possible through the use of technology tools.
The Big6 model follows a six-step approach to processing the
huge amount of information found on the Internet: defining the task;
establishing strategies for finding information and locating resources;
and accessing, using, evaluating, and synthesizing the information
found.
For
more information about the Big6 Skills Approach, visit the
web sites below.
The
Big6 Skills Approach
The official Big6 web site includes creative lesson plans,
assignment and research paper organizers and forms, articles, and
additional sources of research.
www.big6.com
Learning
and Teaching Information Technology Computer Skills in Context
(Scroll down to Technology
Skills for Information Problem Solving: A Curriculum Based
on the Big6 Skills Approach)
Created by Michael B. Eisenberg, Doug Johnson, and Robert E. Berkowitz,
this curriculum is based on the Big6 Skills Approach.
www.ericdigests.org/2003-1/skills.htm
Nuts
& Bolts of the Big6: In Search of Information Literacy
This site contains an overview of the Big6, treasure hunts
and WebQuests, a game for 5th and 6th graders, an information problem-solving
scrapbook activity, and an outstanding list of links to other related
resources surrounding the Big6 and Filamentality (a tool that
guides students through the online research process).
www.kn.pacbell.com/wired/big6/
Skills Students
Need
There
are four important reasons why adolescents must develop Internet
research skills:
1.
Students need to be prepared for the new media generation.
Simply
put, because the Internet is the fastest growing communications
medium in history (Gilster, 1997), teachers need to teach students
how to use it. Teachers must be able to translate the same information-gathering,
problem-solving, and critical thinking skills they are teaching
offline, plus methods for becoming media literate for this new online
learning environment.
For
further reading, see:
Information
Literacy: An Overview of Design, Process and Outcomes
This paper outlines the major components of student research and
information literacy, taking the user through the eight major steps
in the design process. Developed for NoodleTeach - 21st Century
Literacies, this document draws from the work of other outstanding
research in the field of online research and information acquisition.
www.noodletools.com/debbie/literacies/
information/1over/infolit1.html
2.
Research skills will help students deal with the overwhelming complexities
of the Internet.
The
Internet is complex. As with all media, students must be taught
processes for seeking information from multiple wells, methods for
discerning fact from opinion, ways of judging and analyzing information,
strategies for combining information to support opinions, and systems
for recognizing bias. Unless students are taught the necessary skills
to construct and deconstruct meaning from the Internet, they will
likely skim the Web without rhyme or reason, delivering pages of
printable information to the teacher without any understanding of
the content.
For
further reading, see:
Learning
in a Digital Age: Insights into the IssuesThe Skills Students
Need for Technological Fluency
This paper examines the issues and skills students need to be prepared
for the future. It examines technological fluency and information
literacy skills in the age of the Internet, reviews state and district
approaches for setting technology standards, and offers promising
project examples.
www.mff.org/pubs/ME164.pdf
3.
Students can build related expertise.
As
students learn valuable online research skills, they will also be
developing and improving a secondary, equally important set of competencies.
These include, for example, word processing, telecommunications,
multimedia, writing, editing, organization, annotation, collaboration,
independence, creative thinking, and individualized expression.
These are fundamental, literacy-focused, digital competencies that
students need to compete in the 21st century.
For
further reading, see:
Beyond
Classroom Boundaries: Constructivist Teaching with the Internet
This article describes the theory of learning called Constructivism
and the role the Internet plays in enhancing reading, writing, and
research activities. The author examines this role in terms of empowering
students and enabling them to examine complex ideas, direct their
own learning, publish their work, and learn through meaningful social
interactions. This article also includes links to web sites and
projects that have used this approach to teaching.
www.readingonline.org/electronic/elec_index.asp?
HREF=/electronic/RT/constructivist.html
4.
Internet research supports critical thinking skills.
Internet
research is an authentic learning activity that motivates students
to use their critical thinking skills in order to locate information
online. Internet research also encourages individual and collaborative
inquiry, actively engages students in acquiring knowledge, and offers
pathways for teachers to structure learning around solving specific
problems and exploring new ideas.
For
further reading, see:
WEB
LITERACY and Critical Thinking: A Teacher's Tool Kit
Developed by educational technologist Judy Salpeter, this straightforward
guide provides a comprehensive overview and examples of classroom
activities that teach students how to find, evaluate, and synthesize
Internet resources.
www.techlearning.com/db_area/archives/TL/2003/03/toolkit.html
In
addition, the International Society for Technology in Education
(ISTE), funded by the U.S. Department of Education, has developed
the National Educational Technology Standards (NETS) Project.
Forty-four states have already adopted, tailored, or reviewed NETS
for implementation with students, teachers, and administrators.
Internet research falls within all six of NETS' Technology Foundation
Standards for Students. For more information about NETS, go to cnets.iste.org/
Lastly,
for a comprehensive chart that compares the Big6 Information
Literacy Skills to the National Information Literacy Standards
(developed by the American Association of School Librarians {AASL},
the Association for Educational and Communications Technology {AECT},
and NETS), go to: www.surfline.ne.jp/janetm/big6info.htm
Paraphrasing
Arguably
the most important skill students need to learn when conducting
research is how to take another person's idea and translate it into
their own words. The process of paraphrasing requires careful instruction,
one that all students must be taught as they learn how to cite original
sources in their work. Listed below are web sites containing information
and strategies to help students learn how to paraphrase.
Sites
That Matter
Writing-Plagiarism
Advice for Lessons: Grades 1-12
An Apple Learning Interchange Learning Resource, this document provides
suggestions to teachers and parents to help students avoid plagiarism.
henson.austin.apple.com/edres/ellesson/elem-writplagerism.shtml
Paraphrase:
Write it in Your Own Words
This handout defines paraphrasing, describes why it is important,
provides six steps to effectively paraphrasing, provides examples
of acceptable and plagiarized text, and offers an exercise on paraphrasing
with sample answers.
owl.english.purdue.edu/handouts/research/r_paraphr.html
Paraphrasing
Steps and Examples
This is an instructional resource for teaching students how to paraphrase.
This web site provides steps to paraphrasing, gives examples, and
then takes students through an exercise in paraphrasing that includes
a model to compare their work with when they are finished.
oregonstate.edu/~healeyd/162/162paraphrase.html
On
Plagiarism
This section of the Safety 'Net at 2Learn.ca provides guidelines,
strategies, curriculum activities, worksheets, classroom policies,
and additional resources for preventing plagiarism in the K-12 classroom.
www.2learn.ca/mapset/SafetyNet/plagiarism/plagiarism1.html
Anti-Plagiarism
Strategies for Research Papers
This is a compilation of awareness, prevention, and detection strategies
for avoiding plagiarizing. Author of The Plagiarism Handbook,
Robert Harris provides student and teacher approaches for avoiding
plagiarism when writing research papers. www.virtualsalt.com/antiplag.htm
The
New Plagiarism: Seven Antidotes to Prevent Highway Robbery in an
Electronic Age
Jamie McKenzie describes the "new plagiarism" and outlines
seven key solutions for preventing and minimizing plagiarism brought
on by electronic technology.
www.fno.org/may98/cov98may.html#
Also
see our sections on tracking and citing information
and graphic organizers.
Teaching Tips
When
developing a lesson that incorporates the Internet, teachers should
take into account both the benefits and potential risks associated
with this new medium.
Developed
by Literacy Matters, below are 10 Tips for Teaching Internet
Research Skills that should be incorporated into every lesson
plan.
- Internet
safety tips and rules should always be introduced to students
before they begin conducting research online. Students should
be made aware of what to do if they happen upon a site that is
inappropriate or makes them feel uncomfortable.
- Always
supervise students when they are using the Internet in the classroom.
- Allow
students to use search engines to locate specific information
that they are looking for. Never let them surf the Web arbitrarily.
- Share
with students the tools necessary to conduct research online.
For more information, see the Finding Information
section on this site.
- Teach
students about plagiarism, how to cite resources, and strategies
for paraphrasing before they go online. Require students to record
in a bibliographic format the URLs of the sites they have used.
Introduce helpful online and offline tools for keeping track of
resources. For more information, see the Tracking
and Citing Information section.
- Do
not send the entire class to the same site at the same time. If
there are multiple computers in the classroom, use classroom management
strategies that optimize research time on and off the Internet.
- Computer-mediated
communication is an excellent vehicle for supplementing research,
both through online experts and peers around the world. However,
teachers should never allow students to communicate with any individual
on the Internet with whom they (the teachers) have not communicated
first.
- Create
worksheets with hotlinks, develop a web page with hyperlinks,
and/or bookmark approved web sites ahead of time. These are excellent
strategies for a) making use of limited classroom time and b)
controlling students' exposure to inappropriate sites.
- Always
preview web sites before sending students to visit them. Evaluate
them for quality and appropriateness. For more on evaluating web
sites, see the Evaluating Information
section.
- Embrace
the many possibilities the Internet holds for classroom research
projects.
Sites
That Matter
There
are a variety of ways that teachers can use the Internet with their
students to conduct research. Below we have provided a few of our
favorite sites.
Filamentality:
Helping you add your Filament to the web of learning
This web site provides an interactive, fill-in-the-blank tool that
guides users through the process of selecting a topic, finding information
online, gathering high-quality sites, and creating web-based activities
from the online resources and links.
www.kn.pacbell.com/wired/fil/
Module
Maker
Developed by Jamie McKenzie, this site provides a step-by-step guide
that walks teachers through the process of creating their own online
research modules.
questioning.org/module/module.html
Using
the Internet to Promote Inquiry-based Learning: An epaper about
a structured approach for effective student Web research
This paper describes an eight-step process that guides students
through the online research process. Following an inquiry-based
learning approach to conducting research on the Web, this article
provides details, examples, and links.
www.biopoint.com/inquiry/ibr.html#
Tales
from the Electronic Frontier
A
compilation of stories by 10 teachers who share their experiences
around incorporating the Internet into their K-12 science and math
research projects, experiments, and investigations.
www.wested.org/tales/
Inspiration
Inspiration is designed to assist middle and high school students as they gather information and write research projects. Inspiration's tools help students organize their ideas, communicate their thinking to peers and teachers, and identify possible relationships between concepts by creating outlines and graphic organizers in preparation for writing.
www.inspiration.com/
Kidspiration
K-5 learners can use Kidspiration to create graphic organizers and outlines for research projects using pictures, text, and spoken words. Using the software, students can organize their thoughts and ideas, communicate their thinking to peers and teachers, and identify possible relationships between concepts.
www.inspiration.com/productinfo/kidspiration/index.cfm
|